All Star Pizza Reviews

I ordered pizza for pickup through allstar-pizza.com. It was supposed to be ready at a certain time, but I ended up waiting about 10 extra minutes. Not a huge deal, but a little annoying. The staff seemed busy and were polite enough. The pizza itself was decent, nothing amazing, but not bad either. The only thing that really bugged me was how aggressive the reminders were. I kept getting nudged like I was going to forget I ordered a pizza. I might go back if I’m already nearby, but I wouldn’t make a special trip.

I ordered from Allstar Pizza online last night, and it was smooth. Menu loaded without any issue, checkout didn’t give me trouble, and I got confirmation right away.
The pizza showed up hot, and everything in order was correct, which was really all I cared about. I’ll definitely use the site again next time I’m craving pizza.

I really enjoyed this pizza. The crust had that nice chewy texture, and the sauce wasn’t overly sweet, which is a big plus for me. The cheese and toppings tasted fresh and had good flavor too. It was simple, but in a really satisfying way, if that makes sense. I’d definitely order it again

I’ve ordered from All Star Pizza quite a few times now, and it’s been solid every single time. The pizza always arrives tasting fresh, never dry or like it was thrown together in a rush.

I really like that the crust and toppings are consistent from order to order, which isn’t always the case with other pizza places. It’s simple, good pizza, and I’ve even recommended it to a friend because I keep having a good experience

The menu has a ton of pizza options, which is nice, but it took way more effort than I expected just to decide what to order

It was kinda alright overall. Nothing really stood out to me, but it wasn’t bad either...

The delivery was reliable, which is kind of all I was hoping for. It showed up when expected, no weird delays or anything that made me wonder what was going on, so yeah, overall it was a smooth enough experience.

I was just there recently and the staff were so helpful. Maybe it stood out because it’s fresh in my mind, but they made the whole experience really easy and pleasant.

The pizza showed up on time and tasted good, so credit where it’s due. That said, we specifically asked for no onions on one of the pizzas, and of course it still had onions. One of the dips we paid extra for was missing too, which was a nice little bonus. Not the end of the world, but it’s a bit annoying when the details are literally on the order. I’d probably order again, assuming someone feels like double-checking next time.

I ordered from All Star Pizza last night, and to be fair, it got here in a reasonable amount of time. The pizza wasn’t piping hot, but it was still warm enough that I didn’t feel like I needed to throw it in the oven right away, which I appreciated.

The wings had cooled down a bit more than I would’ve liked, but they still tasted good, so I can’t really complain too much. If everything had arrived just a little hotter, I’d probably give it 5 stars. Overall, I was happy with the order and would definitely try them again.

In the end, I walked out still hungry and feeling like it wasn’t worth the price. The food itself was fine, but the portions were so tiny that it felt like barely enough to count as a meal.

I’ve ordered this a few times now, and the veggies always taste super fresh. Definitely something I appreciate and would order again.

I thought the pizza tasted good overall, but for me, the prices felt a bit on the high side. Not bad at all, just maybe a little more expensive than I’d expect.

The discount code worked fine, so no complaints there. I just thought the offer would be a bit better than it was. If you're already planning to buy something, it's still a nice little savings, but I wouldn't say it's the kind of deal that would make me place an order on its own...